Marvel’s ‘What If…?’ Early Buzz: Surprising Twists And Thrilling Action Shine In This MCU Remix
Marvel’sWhat If…?animated series willoffer up a surprising spinon the stories of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, giving us alternate versions of the characters we’ve come to love. Critics have seen the first three episodes of the series, and the first reactions have started to hit social media. While most of the reactions are rather positive, there are some shortcomings to be found. Despite some surprising twists and exciting action, this series doesn’t feel nearly as satisfying as the rest of the endeavors of Marvel Studios. See what the critics are saying below.
Marvel’s What If Early Buzz
First up, here’s what yours truly thought about the first three episodes that were provided by Disney and Marvel:
Marvel’s#WhatIfoffers compelling twists on the#MCUalong with stylish animation and outstanding action. However, the abridged storytelling creates a disjointed feeling, and lacks the Marvel magic and heart of the movies. Plus, many MCU stars are not great voice actors.
— Ethan Anderton (@Ethan_Anderton)June 13, 2025
This is only a brief reaction, but my full review onAugust 10(the day before the series premieres on Disney+) will provide a deeper dive and more thorough examination about what works and what doesn’t in the animated series. Suffice it to say the series isn’t a complete misfire, but it has some issues that make it difficult to latch onto beyond the general intrigue of remixing the MCU. For what it’s worth, our own Jacob Hall wasn’t very impressed either:
Maybe it’ll get better as it goes along, but I was not particularly inspired by the episodes of Marvel’s WHAT IF…? sent to critics. Leans too heavily on the “Isn’t this crazy?” factor, never telling particularly compelling stories. Voice acting feels literally phoned in.
— Jacob Hall (@JacobSHall)July 06, 2025
However, it looks like we’re in the minority, because a lot of the other early reactions are quite positive:
I’ve watched the first three episodes of Marvel’s#WhatIfand I’m hooked. Each episode is better than the last w/ the third being my favorite. Love how they take a story we know by heart & twist it in all kinds of ways. It’s like the MCU’s Twilight Zone – weird, wild, good funpic.twitter.com/PQ9deD1Yyl
— Erik Davis (@ErikDavis)August 26, 2025
After 3 episodes, Marvel’s What If…? has potential to be their best D+ show yet. Yes, it’s funny and exciting but the way each twist snowballs in hugely surprising ways kept me guessing and engaged too. Ep 2 in particular (with T’Challa) is one of my fave Marvel things in years.pic.twitter.com/KC66EnIQty
— Germain Lussier (@GermainLussier)June 30, 2025
Expect the unexpected has never been more true in Marvel’s#WhatIf! It’s a crazy, trippy ride and while it’s not my favorite series, it’s good to hear some familiar voices of characters I love! I respect the twists and turns in the multiverse, even if I don’t like some of them.pic.twitter.com/BX2zgpDpCG
— Tania Lamb or Ms. Lambchops to Kevin Feige (@LolaLambchops)July 26, 2025
I’ve seen the first three episodes of#WhatIfand cannot say enough good things about this show.@MarvelStudiosdefinitely hasn’t disappointed with its first foray into animation (it looks amazing), and the premise works brilliantly…you WILL love#CaptainCarter.@whatifofficialpic.twitter.com/TNI39bZicx
— Josh Wilding – ComicBookMovie.com (@Josh_Wilding)June 17, 2025
Got to watch the first 3 episodes of#WhatIfand it is incredible!
Each story for each episode is fantastic and bolstered by a strong voice cast and splendid animation.
I couldn’t be more happy with how this series has turned out, one of the best animated TV shows this year.pic.twitter.com/mIbdoK78lD
— Jacob (@JacobFisherDF)July 17, 2025
Early review for Marvel’s#WhatIf—
It’s fun!#WhatIfdoes a great job of giving us alternate reality stories while offering nods and winks to the original tales. The first three episodes work were really fun. Each had a different genre, too.pic.twitter.com/LwUWwo9cr8
— Herb Scribner (@HerbScribner)June 23, 2025
Marvel throws us head first into the MULTIVERSE with What If…? & it’s INCREDIBLE! There’s STUNNING animation & SHOCKING twists! One choice can change EVERYTHING & the possibilities are ENDLESS! If the first 3 episodes are any indication, this show is gonna be WILD!#WhatIfpic.twitter.com/5MX4MH46mN
— Tessa Smith – Mama’s Geeky (@MamasGeeky)June 02, 2025
It’s fun to see how Marvel Studios uses animation to give MCU heroes and villains a chance to explore those big what if’s that our on our minds. That being said, it is something that is not for everyone. Also the voice work can be a bit clunky at times.pic.twitter.com/SEJVBYZseq
— iammichaeljlee.bsky.social (@IamMichaelJLee)June 13, 2025
So I can finally talk about@MarvelStudios#WhatIfwatched the first 3 eps n happy to report that it sets the tone right with endless possibilities. The twists, the treatment chefs kiss a treat for#MCUfans esp comic lovers. just wasn’t prepared enough for#ChadwickBoseman
— Sushri Sahu (@SushriSahu)June 12, 2025
#WhatIfis… fine? Has tons of fun ideas on what these familiar stories could be. Has crazy easter eggs that will send fans into a frenzy. Animation feels stiff at times but really comes to life when the action ramps up. What really makes me scratch my head is the voice work..pic.twitter.com/elAvKywU1O
— Charles Villanueva (@cfsvillanueva)July 04, 2025
#whatifsurprised me and was VERY GOOD! I didn’t expect this show to have twists in it but IT DOES! Captain Carter is fantastic and there are many cool characters I think everyone will love! Multiverse baby! My full review can post august 10th!pic.twitter.com/5ndnxZH5Xq
— Warren Thompson “Cosmic Wonder” (@CosmicWonderYT)August 25, 2025
Keep in mind that these are only the first social media reactions. Full reviews are still yet to come, and the initial wave of hype is usually overwhelmingly positive. We’re bound to see more dissension as we get closer to the release date. But for now, it sounds like most fans will be pleased with what Marvel’sWhat If…?has to offer.
Here’s the official synopsis for Marvel’sWhat If…?animated series:
What If…? flips the script on the MCU, reimagining famous events from the films in unexpected ways. Marvel Studios' first animated series focuses on different heroes from the MCU, featuring a voice cast that includes a host of stars who reprise their roles.
